Compact EVs: Mini Cooper SE vs. Fiat 500e Review
As the automotive industry accelerates toward electrification, compact electric vehicles (EVs) are gaining traction among urban drivers and eco-conscious consumers. Combining style, efficiency, and practicality, these small EVs are perfect for navigating crowded city streets while reducing carbon footprints. Two standout models in this segment are the Mini Cooper SE and the Fiat 500e. Both vehicles offer unique takes on the compact EV formula, but how do they stack up against each other? In this review, we’ll compare their design, performance, range, technology, and overall value to help you decide which one might be the better fit for your lifestyle.
Design: Retro Charm Meets Modern Innovation
The Mini Cooper SE and Fiat 500e both draw inspiration from their iconic gasoline-powered predecessors, but each takes a distinct approach to design.
Mini Cooper SE: The Mini Cooper SE retains the classic Mini aesthetic, with its rounded headlights, short overhangs, and playful styling. The electric version is nearly indistinguishable from its internal combustion counterpart, aside from subtle yellow accents and a blanked-off grille. Inside, the cabin is driver-focused, with a circular central infotainment screen, premium materials, and customizable ambient lighting. It’s a modern interpretation of a beloved design, appealing to those who want a familiar look with an electric twist.
Fiat 500e: The Fiat 500e, on the other hand, takes a more futuristic approach while still paying homage to its retro roots. Its exterior features cleaner lines, a minimalist front grille, and sleek LED lighting. The interior is more avant-garde, with a minimalist dashboard, a large touchscreen, and sustainable materials like seaqual yarn (made from recycled plastic). The 500e feels like a fresh start for the Fiat 500, targeting a younger, design-conscious audience.
Verdict: If you prefer a timeless, sporty design, the Mini Cooper SE is the way to go. However, if you’re drawn to a more modern and eco-friendly aesthetic, the Fiat 500e takes the lead.
Performance: Fun vs. Practicality
When it comes to performance, these two EVs cater to slightly different driving preferences.
Mini Cooper SE: The Mini Cooper SE is known for its go-kart-like handling, a hallmark of the Mini brand. Its electric motor delivers 181 horsepower and 199 lb-ft of torque, allowing it to accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in just 6.9 seconds. The low center of gravity, thanks to the underfloor battery pack, enhances its agility and cornering capabilities. While it’s not the most powerful EV on the market, it’s undeniably fun to drive, especially in urban environments.
Fiat 500e: The Fiat 500e is more focused on efficiency and comfort. Its 117-horsepower motor provides adequate power for city driving, with a 0-60 mph time of around 9 seconds. The ride is smooth and composed, making it ideal for daily commutes. However, it lacks the sporty edge of the Mini Cooper SE, prioritizing ease of use over performance.
Verdict: For driving enthusiasts, the Mini Cooper SE is the clear winner. But if you’re looking for a comfortable, no-fuss ride, the Fiat 500e is a solid choice.
Range and Charging: Which Goes the Distance?
Range is a critical factor for any EV buyer, and here, the Fiat 500e has a slight advantage.
Mini Cooper SE: The Mini Cooper SE offers an EPA-estimated range of 114 miles on a full charge. While this is sufficient for city driving and short trips, it falls short compared to many competitors. Charging times are reasonable, with a 0-80% charge taking about 36 minutes on a DC fast charger.
Fiat 500e: The Fiat 500e boasts a slightly better range of 149 miles (EPA estimate), making it more versatile for longer commutes or weekend getaways. It also supports faster charging, reaching 80% in just 35 minutes on a DC fast charger. Additionally, the 500e offers a heat pump as standard, which helps preserve range in colder weather.
Verdict: The Fiat 500e’s longer range and faster charging capabilities give it the edge in this category.
Technology and Features: Cutting-Edge vs. User-Friendly
Both vehicles come equipped with modern tech, but their approaches differ.
Mini Cooper SE: The Mini Cooper SE features a 5.5-inch digital driver display and an 8.8-inch circular touchscreen with Mini’s intuitive infotainment system. Apple CarPlay is standard, but Android Auto is notably absent. The cabin also includes customizable ambient lighting and a heads-up display (optional). While the tech is functional, it doesn’t feel as cutting-edge as some competitors.
Fiat 500e: The Fiat 500e shines in this department, offering a 10.25-inch touchscreen with a user-friendly interface. It supports both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, catering to a wider audience. The 500e also includes advanced driver-assistance features like adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assist, which are optional or unavailable on the Mini.
Verdict: The Fiat 500e offers a more comprehensive and inclusive tech package, making it the better choice for tech-savvy buyers.
Price and Value: Which Offers More Bang for Your Buck?
Pricing is a key consideration, especially in the compact EV segment.
Mini Cooper SE: The Mini Cooper SE starts at around $34,225 (before incentives). While it’s not the most affordable option, its premium build quality and driving dynamics justify the price for many buyers.
Fiat 500e: The Fiat 500e is slightly more affordable, with a starting price of $32,500. It also offers better range and more standard features, making it a better value proposition overall.
Verdict: The Fiat 500e provides more value for the money, especially for budget-conscious buyers.
Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?
The Mini Cooper SE and Fiat 500e are both excellent compact EVs, but they cater to different audiences. The Mini Cooper SE is perfect for drivers who prioritize fun, sporty handling and a timeless design. On the other hand, the Fiat 500e appeals to those who want a modern, eco-friendly vehicle with better range, more tech, and a lower price tag.
